Al's New York Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Al's New York Pizza offers a diverse menu that captures the essence of classic Italian-American cooking.

Start with a slice of authentic NY-style pizza topped with rich marinara sauce and your choice of fresh ingredients.

Craving something different? Try the canolis, these delightful pastries filled with sweet ricotta will leave you wanting more.

Garlic knots and pesto cheesy bread are perfect companions for your pizza, adding a burst of flavor to every meal.

Take a look at hearty pasta options like cheese tortellini or sausage and peppers. For sandwiches, indulge in an Italian combo or a chicken cutlet sub, guaranteed to satisfy your hunger.

The menu also features a selection of salads, sides, desserts, and a fine selection of beverages including wine and beer, ensuring something for everyone.

Featured Dishes

Pizzas
Pizzas
Pepperoni Calzone
Pepperoni Calzone
12 Pepperoni Pizza
12 Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Fried Zucchini Sticks
18' Inch Cheese Pizza with Mushrooms and Pepperoni
18' Inch Cheese Pizza with Mushrooms and Pepperoni
Sausage Onions and Olive Pizza
Sausage Onions and Olive Pizza
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Berry Tiramisu Cake
Berry Tiramisu Cake
Sausage and Peppers Sub
Sausage and Peppers Sub
Lasagna with Garlic Knots
Lasagna with Garlic Knots
Pesto Cheese Bread
Pesto Cheese Bread
Salami
Salami
Garlic Naan
Garlic Naan
Cannelloni
Cannelloni
Al's New York Pizza Menu image 1
Al's New York Pizza Menu image 2
Al's New York Pizza Menu image 3
Al's New York Pizza Menu image 4
Al's New York Pizza

Al's New York Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Stepping into Al's New York Pizza, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance between cozy and vibrant, reminiscent of classic pizzerias.

Walls adorned with iconic New York memorabilia give it a warm, inviting feel, making it ideal for families and diners seeking a friendly atmosphere.

The open kitchen allows guests to watch the magic unfold as skilled chefs create delicious pizzas and other dishes right before their eyes.

Whether gathered around a table with friends sharing a plethora of plates or grabbing a quick bite, the space fosters a sense of community.

This eatery stands out as a local hangout, cultivating an atmosphere where laughter and great food fill the air.

Al's New York Pizza

About Al's New York Pizza Food and Specialties

Al's New York Pizza isn't just about pizza; it excels in crafting traditional Italian staples that resonate with local tastes.

The specialty pies showcase vibrant toppings, fresh mozzarella, and a perfectly baked crust that has become a community favorite.

Signature dishes like the antipasto salad burst with flavor and freshness, unconventional yet beloved by patrons.

Taking comfort food to the next level, their calzones and meatballs serve as hearty, filling options that carry homemade goodness.

Desserts like tiramisu and lemon cake provide a sweet ending, allowing guests to indulge after their savory meals.

Al's New York Pizza celebrates a culinary heritage that invites both locals and visitors to enjoy an authentic slice of New York right here in Barboursville.

Al's New York Pizza

Al's New York Pizza is committed to delivering not just food but a celebration of flavors. The specialty lies in their New York-style pizza, where each pie reflects a dedication to quality and taste. The vision is clear: to create a dining experience that marries cherished recipes with a modern twist, catering to the diverse tastes of the Barboursville community. From the hand-tossed crusts to the fresh ingredients, every aspect of the meal showcases a commitment to excellence. Al's encourages community connections, valuing interactions as much as servings. This commitment to hospitality and flavor is what sets Al's apart as not just a meal destination, but as a beloved community hub.