Al's New York Pizza

Discover authentic NY-style pizza at Al's New York Pizza in Barboursville, WV. Enjoy delicious calzones, garlic knots, cannolis, and more! Call +1 304-955-5461 to order today.

Welcome to Al's New York Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza

Al's New York Pizza opens its doors to a warm and inviting atmosphere that reflects the vibrant spirit of Barboursville, WV. This local gem specializes in authentic New York-style pizza, crafted with care and passion. The moment you step inside, the rich aroma of freshly baked pies and the subtle hints of garlic greet you, setting the stage for a satisfying meal. Beyond pizza, Al's menu features a variety of mouthwatering options—from calzones to garlic knots, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a family dinner, Al's offers a friendly and relaxed environment that encourages community gatherings. Plus, with convenient delivery options, enjoying a taste of New York has never been easier. Discover the flavors that make Al's a local favorite.

Al's New York Pizza boasts a diverse menu with 54 exciting dishes that cater to all tastes. Pizza lovers can indulge in traditional pies, complete with delicious marinara and a perfectly baked crust. For those craving variety, the pasta dishes range from classic marinara to hearty meat sauce and cheesy tortellini. Sandwich enthusiasts enjoy options like the Italian Combo and Chicken Cutlet, providing satisfying choices for lunch or dinner. Don't overlook the sides, offering treats like garlic bread with cheese and spicy Italian sausage.

Families can find kid-friendly items on the kids' menu, featuring favorites like chicken tenders and grilled cheese. Al's also offers a selection of local beers and wines to complement any meal, making it a go-to spot for casual dining.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

5636 US-60 APT 4, Barboursville, WV 25504, United States

Phone

+1 304-955-5461

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza
Al's New York Pizza

Al's New York Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it's a culinary landmark in Barboursville. Founded with a passion for sharing authentic New York-style pizza, Al's takes pride in using high-quality ingredients sourced from local suppliers. The pizza dough rises overnight, ensuring a chewy yet crispy crust that pairs perfectly with their house-made marinara sauce.

The menu is a treasure trove of Italian-American classics. From antipasto salads bursting with flavors to cannoli that satisfy the sweetest tooth, every dish tells a story of tradition and taste. The restaurant's wide array of salads, sandwiches, and pastas guarantees that even non-pizza lovers leave happy. Try the flavorful pesto cheesy bread or the hearty sausage and peppers served over pasta for a truly delightful experience.

Al's provides a welcoming space for gatherings, whether it's a quick lunch with coworkers or a leisurely dinner with family. The staff is friendly and attentive, creating a community vibe that feels like home. It's not uncommon to see regulars chatting with the staff or strangers bonding over shared meals at communal tables. Each visit offers a chance to connect over shared flavors, making Al's a cherished part of the neighborhood.

In addition to dine-in options, Al's caters to busy lives with efficient takeout and delivery services. This flexibility makes it a favorite among local residents seeking a convenient yet delicious meal at home. Every dish at Al's is crafted to create not just meals but memories shared over great food.

Al's New York Pizza

Al's New York Pizza features a charming exterior that invites guests to step inside. The bright signage and welcoming entrance stand out on US-60, making it easy to spot. Outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy their meals al fresco, soaking in the vibrant community atmosphere of Barboursville. The vibe is casual and friendly, with an energetic hum of laughter and conversation that creates a lively dining experience. Whether you're visiting for a quick slice or planning to savor a full meal, Al's provides a comfortable backdrop that feels just like your favorite pizzeria back in New York.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday12-9 PM
  • Wednesday12-9 PM
  • Thursday12-9 PM
  • Friday12-9 PM
  • Saturday12-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

If you want an authentic experience I would recommend Al's!!! As soon as Al started talking we knew the pizza would be legit. The pizza delivered, it was exactly what I was looking for. We even added on some garlic knots because they were freshly baked. If you're looking for a crisp NY style pizza, you should stop in!!

E
EllyP

This is such a hidden gem! Yesterday I, my wife and our son went to Al's, it took me a while to come as the reviews was mixed. I figured we could try it for ourselves and I'm so glad we did! If you've been to New York and had pizza, soon as you walk into this place, you're right back! The biggest difference to me or what I could tell was Al's is 10x cleaner than any place in New York (Probably any place around here, it was spotless). The decor for sure put you in the big city. The waitress came, took our order and the food was out in no time. My wife got a salad and some deep fried mozzarella, myself and my son had pizza. The salad was as fresh as it could be with a large helping. The pizza....the pizza!!! It was amazing ! The ingredients was top notch, you could taste the freshness and quality. The pizza slices was only $3.50 each and two had me throwing in the towel. Al came over to our table after preparing our amazing meal and talked with us briefly. The atmosphere, food, service, everything was absolutely amazing. Overall I would rate Al's as the BEST NY style pizza around!

G
Grant H.

If you had kidnapped and blindfolded me, driven me around for a couple of hours and had me try this pizza, I would swear I was back in the city. I've moved all around the US and tried countless "NY style" pizza places, but all failed to deliver until I stumbled here. This is more than a "style" it's the real deal and I couldn't be happier being new to the area that this place exists. Crust was crisp on the outside but still tender on the inside. Perfectly thin but still able to fold and hold itself together with all the ingredients. If you're homesick, this is the place to be. Only thing that's missing is to be able to buy by the slice, but I think i'll just order the large every time. Our waitress was very attentive, kind and offered great suggestions, we will be back soon. Edit: I stand corrected, they offer pizza by the slice T-F from 12-4pm!

J
Jesus D.

Al's New York Pizza is the best Pizza around. Everything is fresh, Al even shreds his own cheese. The Pesto cheese bread is awesome and the marinara sauce taste just the way it's supposed to, not loaded with sugar. It's even better the next day heated up an air fryer.

J
Jamie M.

We recently moved from NYC and I was missing NY pizza here until I found Al. He moved from NYC 6 years ago where he had a pizza place and learned all the tricks for a good NY style pizza I strongly recommend his pizza if you haven't tried it yet.

H
Hovik M.

Perfect New York Pizza and fries! This place was recommended by one of my friends originally from New York. The pizza is perfectly cheesy and gooey. The fries were hot, crisp, and non-greasy. Lunch for two was also very affordable. I'm looking forward to trying dessert next time!

L
Laura F.